#109: The Devil’s Heart (TNG event novel)

This week, the discovery of a mythical artifact rocks the galaxy, but the seemingly innocuous stone has a history more akin to that of a blood diamond. When the Enterprise takes the gem aboard, Picard insists he can quit any time he wants, but the crew begins to get worried when he starts to lose weight, turn pale, and cal the artifact “my precious”. Why does Worf always have to be so Worf? Who’s riding dinosaurs on the holodeck? Will the sonic appliance wars ever end? All this and more in The Devil’s Heart, the book that’s disturbingly warm to the touch.

The Devil’s Heart
Author: Carmen Carter
Pages: 309
Published: April 1993 (hardcover)
Timeline: One month after “I, Borg” (S5E23)
Prerequisites: One character’s actions are motivated by the events of “Unification” (S5E7+8); otherwise, none

A team of Vulcans led by a woman named T’Sara appears to have just made the archaeological breakthrough of the century: they’ve found an artifact which in Vulcan is called the Ko N’ya. Although Mario would insist it’s just a stone, almost all spacefaring cultures recount some version of it in their mythology, and all of them describe an alarming body count left in its wake. That certainly tracks with its discovery at the Vulcan camp: when the Enterprise arrives, all the Vulcans are dead except for T’Sara, who has withdrawn into a Vulcan healing trance. T’Sara warns that “the blood never stops flowing” where the Ko N’ya is concerned, but that’s just crazy old-lady ranting—

Given his reputation as an up-and-coming amateur archaeologist, it comes as no surprise that the discovery of the Ko N’ya intensely piques Picard’s interest. But his behavior with it hanging around the Enterprise becomes more and more erratic, and his decisions become increasingly Heart-centric. He’s rarely seen not cradling it like a baby; he gets antsy about letting Data run tests on it; and he welches on his customary breakfast with Beverly multiple times in a row to let it whisper sweet nothings in his ear. If they don’t figure out what to do with it, Picard’s obsession is on track to bring him down and take the whole ship with him.

The Devil’s Heart is peppered with accounts of previous possessors of the Ko N’ya, which are in fact dreams being had by Picard. To the Klingons, it was known as the Pagrashtak; the Andorians called it Telev’s Bane; even Surak had a brush with it (though unsurprisingly, he had the wisdom even as a child not to have any part of its shenanigans). Without these interludes, The Devil’s Heart could neither reach nor justify event novel length. Nonetheless, they’re reasonably compelling. Most of the non-Enterprise parties pursuing the Heart, however, don’t get developed enough to feel essential. I think the book might have done better to focus more on the people who wanted the Heart than on Picard’s dreams about it, even though I liked those dream passages.

That’s not the only messy part of the book by a long shot. As mentioned just above, many characters who aren’t on the Enterprise are underdeveloped, and a lot of them disappear for long stretches, most notably Camenae, the El-Aurian who, in contrast to Guinan, has grown cynical and decided to monetize her Listening powers. No one else in pursuit of the stone has a major impact on the story, though I did like the callback baked into the Romulans’ undoing. Also, the Ko N’ya’s nature is pretty nebulous—the book can never seem to decide whether it’s a mind-control device embedded in a rock or if it’s vaguely sentient somehow. I also wish it had leaned more into the Heart acting at Picard’s emotional behest—it only starts to do some truly crazy stuff near the end of the story.

There are reasons that are vaguely alluded to in Voyages of Imagination that explain the ramshackle nature of the novel. Carter initially declined to write an event novel because she didn’t have any ideas that could fill out that kind of space, and although she says this one came to her fully formed on a beam of divine light, this one in truth really can’t either. A lot of personal things going on in her life during the writing caused her to miss deadlines and burn out on writing fiction permanently in a professional context (this was her final novel, Trek or otherwise). It does seem like it could have used several more drafts. Star Trek novels are in general rarely what I’d call tightly plotted, but this one misses even that relatively low bar.

Despite what a hot mess The Devil’s Heart is, however, it’s still fairly entertaining. Starbase 193 and Smelter’s Hold both have a Mos Eisley-esque flavor that we’d see more of in the season 7 episode “Gambit”. There’s lots of well-spoken dialogue in this one as well. I’m not usually that big a fan of Dr. Crusher—probably my least favorite Trek doctor, including Pulaski—but I feel like she really crackled with personality in this book in a way that she rarely does on the screen. This book could certainly have been a lot better, but all things considered, it also could have been a lot worse.


  • The MVP of the week is Data, whose lack of organic humanity once again manifests as an asset rather than a liability. Without Data and his strength of ten men, no one’s getting the Ko N’ya out of Picard’s greedy hands. Mostly, though, I just like the way he’s written in this book. Carter has a better grasp of natural-sounding Data dialogue than most writers of these books. Runner-up to Beverly, who gets a lot of unnecessary guff from the crew because they have to miss an inter-ship poker tournament for the detour to take care of T’Sara. It’s not like Beverly gave her the Bendii!
  • My LVP this week is Worf. Worf always treats this kind of stuff like a game, and the Ko N’ya is no exception. To him, the Ko N’ya (or in Klingon, the Pagrashtak) is a means to an end—an end comprising a bloodbath that will end in the securing of a legacy and eternal honor. Like … seriously, dude? Your captain is falling apart here. Come off it already.

Nuggets & Other Stray Bits

  • The Devil’s Heart is the second TNG event novel in a row to feature the Guardian of Forever, albeit not as prominently as Imzadi did, and the people of Iconia and where they ended up are more where her focus lay. Nevertheless, Carter apologizes for this parallel track in the book’s introduction.
  • At first, it’s suspected that T’Sara has succumbed to Bendii syndrome. Is Bendii syndrome going to become to TNG as lupus is to House? Probably too much to ask for, but it would be hilarious.
  • The Iconian diaspora is the sort of thing I could read an entire Star Trek novel about, if Pocket Books would allow that sort of thing.
  • “After adding an extra ten percent exasperation tax to her previously decided on [sic] figure, Camenae firmly stated the cost of the proposed transaction.” — I need to start doing this in real life. I wouldn’t be able to hold all the extra money in my house if I charged an exasperation tax for annoying interactions. (p. 77)
  • Beverly, talking to Deanna about the injuries she’d been dealing with the previous night: “For instance, did you know there’s a holodeck scenario for riding dinosaurs?” Deanna suspects this is the kind of thing Wesley would make, and while that sounded accurate enough at first pass, I did make a small effort to figure out who other than Wesley would use it the most. Barclay kept popping to my head even though that’s obviously incorrect, and I briefly considered that Riker might ride dinosaurs as a clumsy tribute to his own libido. In the end, I pretty much just ended up admitting Deanna was probably right. (p. 213)
  • “Although the commander was driving the base reconstruction effort with a manic zeal that would probably win her a promotion to commodore before the year was out, a few amenities were still lacking. Sonic dishwashers, for one.” — Yes! YES! After a run of passages in various books where it seemed like the Federation had gone back to using good old-fashioned water in their plumbing, Team Sonic finally scores another point in the future-appliance wars. Don’t call it a comeback! (p. 307)

Final Verdict

I give The Devil’s Heart 3 out of 5 sonic dishwashers. Despite being really messy, this one is still reasonably entertaining. A lot of its plot threads get away from it for too long at a stretch and there’s a lot that’s not important or well-developed enough to have made the final cut, but the core premise is strong and carries the book over a lot of rough patches. If you’re looking for a rich Guardian of Forever yarn, you’re better off sticking with Imzadi, but there’s enough here to have a decently good time with.

NEXT TIME: The Enterprise-D crew has their eyes on The Romulan Prize


#108: The Starship Trap (TOS #64)


#110: The Romulan Prize (TNG #26)


  1. Lea

    I haven’t read a Trek novel since I was about fifteen, but I do remember really liking this one, mostly for the dream sequences. But I’ve always been a huge mythology geek — I also think people are harder on the episode “Masks” than it really deserves for essentially the same reason (an opinion that has survived the general souring of my opinion of Brent Spiner’s acting in any role other than regular, non-possessed, pre-emotion-chip Data).

  2. A.D.

    I like this one quite a bit. In Voyages of Imagination, Carmen Carter mentioned that she missed a lot of deadlines while working on this book, and I can see why – there is a lot going on here. As others have mentioned, it really does have an epic feel. She could have doubled the length of the “dreaming” historical sequences and I don’t think I would have become bored. Carmen Carter only did three solo Trek books, and I think she saved her best for last. It’s a shame that the writing process didn’t go smoother, because I think she was a writer with a lot of potential.

    Part of the brilliance of the book is that, for most of it, the reader thinks they are reading a rehash of Frodo’s journey to Mount Doom. In the end, you find out that the motives of the “villains” were a lot more noble than we we assumed.

    You are absolutely right about about Worf being the LVP – he’s really a jerk in this book.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén