#110: The Romulan Prize (TNG #26)

[Sorry this one’s late. Been under the weather the past couple days. —Jess]

This week, the Romulans’ new warbird is harder, better, faster, and stronger, and though its new commander is young, he’s no daft punk, bagging no less a quarry than the mighty Enterprise. Now Picard must scramble to answer questions for a quiz he didn’t know was scheduled on a subject he didn’t know existed. Is Riker a Ninja Turtles fan? Was this book originally about Klingons? When will these books stop having exposition for people who have never heard of Star Trek? All this and more in The Romulan Prize, the book that puts the crew, as you humans say, in quite a pickle.

The Romulan Prize
Author: Simon Hawke
Pages: 279
Published: May 1993
Timeline: Right before Grounded (TNG #25)
Prerequisites: None

Valak has been hand-picked by the Praetor for a new special assignment: command of the new D’Kazanak-class Romulan warbird, which essentially is functionally no different from the D’Deridex class of warbirds, except that it’s twice as big with better maneuvering, more powerful ordnance, and less conspicuous cloaking. Valak’s military record speaks for itself, but what really lands him the job is his close study of humans, in particular Starfleet’s procedures and notable figures—something that makes him a fairly giant weirdo in Romulan culture, but nevertheless the best man for the job.

Cut to the Enterprise, which finds the supersized warbird floating derelict on the wrong side of the Neutral Zone. Boy, they just can’t keep those things running, can they? Ah, but this time, it’s a well-laid trap set by Valak. Evidently all it takes to bag a Galaxy-class starship is a big juicy warbird, some experimental drugs that make you look dead even to a tricorder, and a few acceptable casualties. Whoda thunk?

Valak demands to know what the deal is with Hermeticus II, a planet on the outskirts of the Neutral Zone that’s been quarantined by the Federation for over thirty years. Picard hasn’t even heard of it, but Valak is driving, so, road trip! The Romulans, paranoid as ever, suspect the Federation of setting up a secret base in order to spy on them. The presence of a Constitution-class ship in orbit (the USS Independence, long thought MIA) does nothing to allay their fears. But the question of how a starship, especially one as gutted as the Independence, could hang above a planet for three decades without its orbit decaying may actually be the least weird question on the table. Probes reveal that the seemingly inhospitable planet is in fact hollow, and that it isn’t even a planet, but rather a ship…

The Romulan Prize is the first of three Trek novels we’ll see from Simon Hawke. This one takes a while to establish a rhythm where it doesn’t shoot itself in the foot every few pages. Valak, as mentioned above, is a scholar of humankind, and as such is prone to deploying Terran idioms. This isn’t a problem but the fact that he prefaces every Earth saying with “as you humans say” is. It happens regularly, sometimes more than once a page, and it kills the momentum every time. The book also features jarring amounts of the kind of exposition for people who barely know what Star Trek is. Is anyone’s very first experience with the series really going to be a random novel? Does the person even exist who, twenty-six numbered installments in, needs three pages on the origins of Data, including a recap of “The Measure of a Man”?

Once these bad habits fall by the wayside about halfway through, however, The Romulan Prize settles into a decent groove. It has some pretty interesting bones, and I find Hawke skilled at allowing both the Enterprise crew and the Romulans to take risks on ambitious ideas that actually feel like they have a non-zero chance of not working. Everything must eventually bow to the almighty status quo, of course, so any author who manages to create a credible sense of uncertainty and shooting from the hip is to be commended.

The Romulan Prize isn’t without its issues, but I enjoyed it well enough on the whole. Hawke successfully cultivates an air of mystery and danger in all the right places, and all the pieces add up to a conclusion that zigged just a little bit when I expected it to zag. Valak is that rare specimen, a fun Romulan; his dry demeanor and verbal sparring with Picard are both major highlights. (I often imagined him as a Romulan James Spader.) I could have done without that irritating verbal tic, of course, as well as the info-dumps full of stuff I knew about TNG when I was 10, but overall, this is a solid debut effort.


  • My MVP this week is Riker. All the senior officers are in fine form this week, but Riker seems especially loose and limbered. Riker toys with Valak’s first officer Korak, quickly ascertaining that he has a hair-trigger temper that can be exploited with aikido moves. It was actually really hard to choose a LVP this week, because everyone contributes something meaningful, but Riker pulls out to a wide lead early and maintains it throughout.
  • For LVP this week, I’m calling out Lord Kazanak. The designer of the eponymous double-wide warbird is along for the maiden voyage, but he doesn’t do much of anything and doesn’t cut an imposing figure at all. After Valak and Picard go MIA, Lord Kazanak sends team after team down to the planet-ship to see what’s going on, with no clue that the fact that the teams aren’t coming back means this probably isn’t working. Just kind of a big dum-dum who probably should have stayed home.

Nuggets & Other Stray Bits

  • This is pure speculation, but judging by the way many of the Romulans yell and snarl, and to a lesser extent based on the rhythm of their names, I have a feeling the antagonists of this book might have actually been Klingons in an early draft. Of course, that’s a little more difficult to put across in the world of TNG, where the Federation and the Klingon Empire are at peace with each other, so maybe it was originally a TOS novel? And the USS Independence is a vestige of that early concept? This is some real tinfoil hat talk; feel free to disregard.
  • Valak quickly course-corrects after being chided by Picard for referring to Data as an “it” rather than a “he”: “Valak gave him a slight bow. ‘I stand corrected. No offense intended, Mr. Data.'” — See? Even Romulans respect pronouns. It isn’t hard! (p. 66)
  • Korak, inspecting Riker’s holodeck dojo: “There were bo staffs, nunchuks, sai tridents, kamas or sickles, Japanese swords made both of steel and of wood, spears and shuriken, or throwing stars.” — Riker basically packed his dojo out with the Ninja Turtles starter kit, right? Who do you think Riker’s favorite Ninja Turtle is? That’s a rhetorical question, it’s obviously Leonardo. (p. 99)
  • A somewhat tightly limited naming pool provides unintentional comedy when we meet a Romulan named Jalad. (p. 168)

Final Verdict

I give The Romulan Prize 3 out of 5 D’Kazanak-class warbirds. Simon Hawke makes his Trek debut with a story that starts off rocky with some annoying bad habits and which is padded out with raw information that anyone who’s heard of Star Trek already knows. But once it picks up and sheds those things, it gets good, with character ambition and risk-taking that clock above average for a standard installment of the week. Add in a fun antagonist who makes a great foil for Picard, and you’ve got yourself a book that may not be the first one anyone would reach for, but is serviceable nonetheless.

NEXT TIME: A serial killer stalks Deep Space Nine in The Siege


#109: The Devil’s Heart (TNG event novel)


#111: The Siege (DS9 #2)


  1. June

    Data looks like a biological man and doesn’t use uncommon pronouns. It’s not exactly hard to get his right.

  2. Adam

    …except for the fact that Data is essentially still a robot/machine. Despite what the episode “Measure of a Man” might have you believe. (Seriously, Picard’s slavery “argument” could have very well been applied to an algorithmic DVR or series of marketing software. And, yes, I also recognize Data is “fully functional” much like any device you might purchase from Adam & Eve. So what?)

    I mean, would you call your Roomba a “she?” Ha. Well, maybe.

    The conceit is that we, as a collective culture, have become accustomed to using pronouns for robots and androids thanks to earlier works such as Forbidden Planet and the original Star Wars trilogy. Even Marvel’s Vision was treated as a “he” until John Byrne literally dismantled the character, showing he (or it) was essentially just a machine; Scarlet Witch lost interest and, for years afterward, the Vision was treated as a cold robot. But… It was still called a “he.”

    Anyway, pronoun usage has been totally overblown by the far Left, as most people (at least in the U.S.) are agreeable and have some semblance of politeness and common sense. So no need to apply that non-issue to a Romulan “mischaracterizing” Data.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén