#121: The Big Game (DS9 #4)

This week, when Quark’s poker tournament draws a full house, Odo bets it’ll flop. But when one of the players is murdered, Odo decides to ante up, flush out the culprit, and get some straight answers. Meanwhile, subspace waves cut the station’s decks, and Sisko doesn’t know jack about where they’re coming from. Will he fold under Bajoran and Cardassian pressure? Does he have an ace in the hole? Is Deep Space Nine royally screwed, or is there a solution that suits everyone? All this and more in The Big Game, the book where the deal goes down.

The Big Game
Author: Sandy Schofield
Pages: 276
Published: November 1993
Timeline: Between “The Circle” (S2E2) and “The Siege” (S2E3)
Prerequisites: “The Game” (TNG S5E6) and “A Matter of Time” (TNG S5E9) for certain recurring characters; “The Next Phase” (TNG S5E24) for key plot details

Very few people may care about baseball in the far-flung future, but The Big Game dares to posit that poker may well capture all kinds of alien imaginations. It certainly appeals to Quark, whose Galactic Series of Poker event promises to attract slimeballs and ne’er-do-wells from all across the galaxy, including Grand Nagus Zek; the Duras sisters, Lursa and B’Etor; Berlinghoff Rasmussen, the con man from the 22nd century who once tried to convince the Enterprise-D he was from the 26th; and Phil Hellmuth.

Subspace waves are buffeting the station something fierce, but the tournament proceeds more or less smoothly—that is, until a player gets murdered while the lights are down. Odo, previously content to deride the game from the peanut gallery, comes to the conclusion that the most effective way to sniff out the killer will be to surveil as a contestant—a plan that will require him to learn how to actually play poker, a game he considers completely pointless.

Odo actually makes quick work of the case, which is good for Sisko, who has to deal with the Cardassians believing the subspace waves are a weapon being used against them, the Bajorans denying it, and both itching to fire on each other. But the poker murderer volunteers a hot tip: the waves are probably being caused by a group of poachers operating out of phase to hunt a mythical space animal known to the Bajorans as an Espiritu. A plan forms to refit a runabout to shift out of phase and tell the Ghost Riders to go kick space rocks—and if they don’t succeed, all parties involved may well have another war on their hands.

“Sandy Schofield” is an alias used by the husband-and-wife writing team of Dean Wesley Smith and Kristine Kathryn Rusch, who between them boast an eye-popping number of writing and editing credits. They say they used that name because they thought their full names wouldn’t fit on a cover, though that clearly isn’t the problem they (perhaps jokingly) suggest it is, since we’ll see those long names on plenty of Star Trek covers to come (sort of a reverse L.A. Graf situation). The Big Game is indeed the first of many, though hopefully future installments work out a little better than this one.

Chronologically, The Big Game slots into the beginning of season two, but it feels more like a season-one episode, and not just because George Primmin shows up for two seconds.1 The sense I mean that in is it’s dotted with Next Generation characters who, in this specific context, feel included primarily as lifelines to help us keep our Star Trek bearings in this wacky and disorienting new universe. Think “Q-Less”, or “The Forsaken” (not to bash the latter—I actually really like that one). This might be more appreciated and necessary for TV, but I’m not sure the type of fan who’s into the books requires this sort of hand-holding. That said, the characters that fit that description do have a M.O. for poker that shows mindful consideration; Rasmussen in particular is a good fit for this story, and quite entertaining.

Even without the Next Generation cameos, however, this is still a busy book. The Big Game marks the first non-Emissary novelverse appearance of many characters, major and minor. Garak has a seat at the table, offering a delightful dose of his typical Garak-ness. The Grand Nagus is present as well, though he doesn’t play as significant a role as his involvement might initially lead you to believe. Jake and Nog crawl through various nooks and crannies, peeking in on multiple Ferengi cheating schemes I won’t even begin to pretend I cared about. And it’s good to finally be in the hands of authors who actually understand how Dax talks to Sisko.

Although there’s far more at stake in this story than just a card game, the poker bits are what mainly held my interest. Honestly? Take away the boring cheating junk and the Ghost Rider thread, and I could read a story the size of two event novels about various Trek characters meeting at the poker table, trying to size each other up and figure out their psychology. Naturally, I understand that that’s not exactly a publishable idea, and I can’t hold it against the book since that’s never something it realistically never would have given me, but hey, let a boy dream.

Though I liked several individual components of this book, I wasn’t able to say after finishing it that I liked it on the whole. Sometimes a story adds up to more than the sum of its parts. This one, though? Considerably less. Several passages offer something cool and/or creative, but it never quite coheres into a thing I would all-inclusively call “good”. That’s a shame, but some debuts have been way rockier. There are definitely glimmers of potential, and I feel confident I’ll be thumbs-upping a Smith/Rusch work sooner rather than later.


  • My MVP this week is Odo. Early DS9 authors have shown to be disproportionately fascinated with the amorphous constable, but so far he’s been the most fun here. He solves a murder in just under half a book and goes from considering poker a giant waste of time to loving it and making the final showdown. I won’t spoil how he does, but it’s a lot of fun to watch.
  • Dual LVP this week for Jake and Nog. Their stealth adventure uncovering Ferengi cheating apparatuses amounts to less than nothing, especially considering how much raw skill Zek has at poker to begin with, and their parts of the book are without question the most boring. They could’ve and probably should’ve sat this one out.

Nuggets & Stray Bits

  • Cover Art Corner: What is a Romulan Warbird doing on this cover? They’re not the ones threatening to start a war here. Barely anyone cares that a Romulan was the one who got murdered!
  • Look. I’ve never successfully written a work of fiction. I’ve never stuck my neck out there in that way. I don’t create culture, I comment on it. Some might say I’m part of the problem, as if there was only one. So maybe I should sit down and shut up. But today, I won’t. There is something that needs to be said, and I am the someone to say it. And that thing is: they missed a gigantic opportunity by not calling this novel The Big Deal, right?
  • There’s a reference in here that’s so sly I nearly missed it, but there’s a player in the tournament named Cynthia Jones, who wears a sterilized tribble like a hat and a dress of oft-remarked-upon sheerness. Ring any bells?
  • “‘Oltion Four has a warrant out for him—seems he murdered an entire family just after supper and the Oltonions [sic] want to execute him for it.'” — A shout-out to Jerry and Kathy Oltion, no doubt—names we haven’t seen yet, but will in good time. (p. 35)
  • “Bashir put pressure on the wound, staunching the blood flow.” — I’ve always understood the proper term for stopping the flow of something to be stanching, but even the crappy dictionary I have access to at work lists both as acceptable, so I’m going to guess this is a prescriptivist hill I probably won’t look good dying on. (p. 153)
  • Since the game is being played on an orbital station, does that make it a satellite tournament? Hey, listen, you’ve been great, folks. Be sure to tip your waitresses, and try the veal, it’s the best in the city. And remember, that URL, one more time, is patreon dot com slash deep space spines!

Final Recommendation

Do I recommend The Big GameNegative, Ghost Rider. But it’s a soft opposition. There are a lot of individual parts I liked about it, but they didn’t quite add up to a book I can say I liked. Still, as thumbs-downs go, this is certainly one of the less enervating and annoying ones. Heck, if you like card games, Next Generation cameos, and showdowns with space poachers, you might even see how the mileage varies for yourself. Personally, however, I don’t really see myself wanting to pick this one up again.

NEXT TIME: There’s people in that nebula in Here There Be Dragons


#120: Line of Fire (TNG-YA #2)


#122: Here There Be Dragons (TNG #28)

1 Comment

  1. Adam Goss

    Talk about praising with faint damns! Seriously, I get you totally on the ghost riders plot – the authors could have made this just Star Trek-meets-Maverick and it’d have been way better, but I did enjoy it and am happy to have it on my shelf. The team-up of Smith and Rusch is not a bad one, but I must say Rusch is the stronger of the pairing (I’ve read short stories by her solo and they are good, whereas Smith…. bores me. A lot. He may be better as an editor I think). I also didn’t feel like there was “hand-holding” with the TNG characters, it felt more like fan service (“Oooh look who else just popped up!!”), and that’s not always a bad thing.

    Also, “The Big Deal” sounds like business negotiations. Could be something there though… QUARK SELLS THE STATION! (Boy, Sisko is gonna be piiiiiissed! Now he’s gotta organize a starship wash and Bajoran bake sale…)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén